GUEST COMMENTARY: The Decision Is Not the Only Thing the County Must Protect Douglas Vandergraph https://douglasvandergraph.com
GUEST COMMENTARY
The Decision Is Not the Only Thing the County Must Protect
Douglas Vandergraph
https://douglasvandergraph.com
At 5:45 p.m. on Tuesday, November 17, Spotsylvania County residents are scheduled to have a public hearing about a proposed 555-acre technology campus. The Crossroads proposal includes seven data center buildings and three electrical substations. The hearing will take place at the Holbert Building on Courthouse Road. A meeting this consequential is about more than the land on a map. It is about whether neighbors can speak plainly, receive careful answers, and still recognize one another as neighbors when they leave.
John Williams reported in The Spotsylvania Gazette that the application seeks permission for roughly 2.1 million square feet of data center space near Mills Drive and Benchmark Road. The Planning Commission recommended approval by a 4–2 vote in September. People may reasonably see the proposal differently. Some may be thinking about investment, infrastructure, and future economic opportunity. Others may be thinking about nearby homes and churches, water, the landscape, and the effects of a large facility on daily life. Neither concern becomes unworthy merely because it belongs to someone on the other side of the room.
A public hearing is sometimes described as a chance to speak. That is only half its purpose. It must also be a chance for the people responsible for a decision to listen. For a parent arranging childcare, a worker finishing a shift, or an older neighbor who cannot easily travel, even getting to a meeting can be an act of determination. When residents make that effort, their questions deserve more than a clock and a polite nod.
Here is one practical test of a fair meeting: can the person who disagrees with the majority leave knowing exactly what was considered, what was not yet known, and how the decision will be explained? If the answer is no, even a lawful vote can leave a wound in public trust. A good process does not promise that everyone gets the outcome they want. It promises that people will not be treated as obstacles to be hurried past.
Jesus gave an uncomfortable instruction in Matthew 5:44: love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you. Most neighbors at a county hearing are not enemies at all. But the teaching matters precisely when disagreement tempts us to turn a fellow citizen into a caricature. It asks for something stronger than surface politeness. It asks us to see the other person’s dignity even while arguing firmly against that person’s position.
That does not mean silence. A resident may ask difficult questions about water use, noise, emergency planning, schools, or the reasons supporting a permit. Another may argue that rejecting development carries costs of its own. Both should be encouraged to bring specific evidence and to hear the evidence offered in return. We do not honor Christ by pretending the choice is easy. We honor his teaching when we refuse to lie, ridicule, or reduce a human being to a slogan in order to win.
The Gazette’s report also notes that written comments can be sent to the county Planning Department using application SUP26-0003. That detail matters. Not everyone can reach the Holbert Building for the hearing, and public life should make room for the person whose disability, family responsibility, or work schedule keeps them away. Written participation should be read with the same seriousness as remarks delivered at a microphone. When officials explain a decision afterward, the people who could not attend should be able to understand the reasons, too.
Spotsylvania does not need a room where everyone agrees. It needs a room where hard questions can be asked without contempt, where facts are not replaced by rumors, and where people who lose a vote still have reason to believe they belong. Whatever the county decides about Crossroads, that kind of civic trust will be needed for the next school question, road project, or neighborhood concern. A building may stand for decades. So can the memory of how a community treated its people while deciding whether to build it.
Guest commentaries express the views of their authors.
More News from Spotsylvania Courthouse
- Who is Safeguard Spotsy? The residents’ group behind the Crossroads challenge Who is Safeguard Spotsy? The residents’ group behind the Crossroads challenge
- Spotsylvania supervisors approve Crossroads data center campus in 4–3 vote Spotsylvania supervisors approve Crossroads data center campus in 4–3 vote